My overall experience with PCGameSupply has been very favorable. Almost all of my orders (save for the first one which required some pretty extensive verification) have been fulfilled faster than I can refresh the browser page to obtain my codes. I will say that I feel like frequent customers get shafted a bit, as many sites of this type offer some kind of reward or discount program for repeat customers. I've purchased hundreds of dollars worth of gift card codes from them over the past several months, and I haven't been offered so much as a discount on the "activation fee" they charge. This is a little disappointing.
Overall, if you can't get the gift card you want from local retailers and want to get them quickly, then give them a shot. Otherwise, you can save yourself a lot of money by just buying them at face value.
Connect with Facebook to get one click access to Trustpilot. It's easier.Sign up with Facebook